The Shins: Wincing the Night Away
Sub Pop, 2007
Rating: 3.5
Gem(s): “Red Rabbits”
Why: Classic Shins ebullient mope-rock. Note the well-executed melodic shifts, rising to an emotional peak and then hitting the rewind button.
Keeper(s): “Sleeping Lessons,” “Phantom Limb,” “Turn on Me”
Why: Opener “Lessons” evolves from the watery musings of a chronic insomniac to a satisfyingly meaty rocker, proving the Shins more than capable of shifting their patented sound without sacrificing the group’s core identity. “Limb” marries pointed observations on social martyrdom with wonderful harmonies, and “Turn on Me” showcases the same lithe bounce and spit found on earlier releases, which helps it stand out from the overly labored sound dominating this release.
Not So Much: “Spilt Needles”
Why: Imagine a Shins cover band taking a stab at an original, Shins-inspired tune. This could be it, lacking the masterful hooks of lead singer/writer James Mercer and the sprightly punch of the group’s rhythm section. Call it a B-side someone couldn’t bear to see excised from the final track list.
Pithy Summation: The appealing nursery-rhyme surrealism (cooked geese, red rabbits and a dodo’s conundrum) commenting on real-life issues (primarily of the broken-hearted variety) are ably represented on the Shins’ third long-player. But the hooks are much more muted than on the band’s debut Oh, Inverted World, and overall Wincing the Night Away assumes a less assertive stance than sophomore standout Chutes Too Narrow. Call it the sound of a band hitting the big time a little too self-consciously wary of their strengths (those imminently replayable hooks and cozy harmonies), forcing their less accomplished skills (the Shins aren’t exactly Radiohead when it comes to exploiting all the recording studio has to offer) to the fore.